At 5:33 pm, we asked once again to use a facilities, and were told in no uncertain terms: no, we need to wait until we get the OK from inside. Come here if you want to feel alive. The food presentation is out of this world. Inside, you are to see the beautiful decor. Juliette and Frank Guidara. Phelps has racked up numerous honors since opening Indigenous in 2011, including being named a James Beard "Best Chef" semifinalist twice, winning a Niman Ranch scholarship, achieving top Zagat. We asked to speak to the GM who are as clearly too busy to take care of his patients to bother finding out what was going on. Not to mention their signature handcrafted cocktails. One diner thought the shrimp and scallops was bland, the server offered a replacement dish which was the falafel plate - a big improvement. We were told in no uncertain terms that we could not enter the building until they got word from inside that it was OK to do so. Website. A treat to our palates! Ask any young person and thats the first place theyll tell you to go. MADE Restaurant - 1990 Main St #112, Sarasota. For more information on Indigenous, at 239 S. Links Ave., Sarasota, call 941-706-4740 or visit indigenoussarasota.com. We would highly recommend the lobster roll and sexy woman roll. Perfectly polished wooden tables with Instagram friendly wall decor. Our main dinners went from an extraordinary Cobia dish to an ordinary baked sun shrimp dish. Indigenous Restaurant accepts credit cards. Other than Italian dishes, youll also find Italian plates and Italian themed wall decor. Guests of this restaurant say that they found prices democratic. They have great reviews and amazing happy hour specials. Indigenous is supposedly one of Sarasotas most exciting restaurants. Attentive service. Completely overcooked. We were celebrating our wedding anniversary. One service glitch this year - our server misunderstood my drink order and brought me a glass of cava (which I had cancelled in favor of ordering a bottle of rose' that she recommended) - but she brought me the glass of cava and then immediately poured me a glass of rose'. Directions. Here are some of her top takeout destinations. And while we were curious what the long, thin things were - after one bite I realized they were deliciously cooked/carmelized rainbow carrots! If only wed split the salad we would have been able to enjoy dessert - but as the portion sizes were generous, we were satisfied enjoying our bottle of wine! This is truly a hidden gem right on Main Street. You can dine in or order takeout which is usually very fast. The greens salad was outstanding. Another lovely evening with friends enjoying a delicious meal at my favorite Sarasota restaurant! I mentioned it to the waiter and he told me that it was supposed to be room temperature. Heres why. Every thing we ordered was excellent, from the Thai Shrimp appetizer $16, Mushroom Bisque $9, Black Garlic Caesar salad $12, Arctic Char $36 right down to the Fruity Pebble Blueberry desert special $12 and Dark Choco Mousse $12. An amazing experience! While it does have a sophisticated atmosphere, it can get loud. Indigenous is an "eclectic" source to table restaurant. Its got hip industrial style vibes with romantic lighting. 239 S Links Ave Sarasota FL 34236. More. Are you sure you want to delete this question? Cmon, really? Heres why. As soon as we ordered our appetizers, she tried to push us to order our entrees. Why takeout only? Indigenous, 239 South Links Avenue, Sarasota, FL - Groupon 95 Points - Robert Parker, The 2008 Dominus reveals an explosive nose of red and black fruits intermixed with notes of truffles, earth, soil, forest floor and licorice. We would highly recommend trying chicken parmigiana, tortelloni a la vodka, veal piccata and spaghetti with meatballs. We will be back when we visit Sarasota again! 9,258 were here. And Katy, our server, was very customer experience focused and knowledgable. Also, be forewarnedthere were literally only six entrees to pick from ( that included a hamburger). Yes, Indigenous Restaurant offers takeout. My gazpacho arrived and it was spicy, full of flavour and all mine, no sharing involved, their mushroom bisque and roasted mushroom with truffle hollandaise was divine. They specialize in Asian inspired cuisine, sushi and other Japanese dishes. Their brisket will literally melt in your mouth. Save yourself some money and eat much better, for much less, elsewhere. Makes you feel like youre in Miami with its big city vibes. A Burger A Week - Indigenous - dineSarasota Since they buy from local fishermen, expect a constantly rotating menu of fresh fish. Dont forget to order a craft cocktail from their highly trained and knowledge bartenders. RESTAURANT: INDIGENOUS (239 S. LINKS AVE. (941) 706-4740) DATE OF VISIT: FEBRUARY 7, 2023. Yet another amazing meal! It would be wrong, possibly borderline illegal to come here and not order some German beer. 129 photos. Welcome to Sarasota, Fla.: A Newcomer's Eating Tour A visit to this picturesque pocket of the Sunshine State promises award-winning powdered sugar sand beaches, cotton candy sunsets, salty ocean. The inside seating was just renovated, so we understand if you sit indoors. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews. The food was okay, but nothing to rave about. Price range: $8 - $28 . Delightful to be able to talk and hear our conversation. As flawless and seamless as a 2006 Cabernet from Napa can be. What sounded like a fabulous baked banana cake was actually just OK. With so many outstanding restaurants in Sarasota, not sure we would come back but we are certainly glad we checked it out. Opened in 2011, Indigenous has earned a reputation for being an inspirational and educational restaurant. Outstanding food prep & variety of options to try new things or familiar food in new ways!! Advertisement. Servers are outstanding and do a wonderful job of introducing Chefs creations. STOP #: 21 OF 52. 239 S Links Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236-6926 +1 941-706-4740. They try very hard but taste is missing. There are far better restaurants in Sarasota, Meliora, Kojo, Baker and Wife(their burger is actually quite fabulous),Rosemary and Thyme etc. My burger was a notch below Shake Shak , a NY fast food restaurant. 239 S Links Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236-6926 Website Email +1 941-706-4740 Improve this listing Details Manage this business? The ultimate triumvirate. crunchy chickpeas, basil yogurt, garam masala, kale, basil, romaine, parmesan, marinated tomatoes, cornbread croutons, Dakin Dairy mozzarella, baby arugula, mint, spiced almonds, peas, yuzu vanilla vinaigrette, slow cooked Niman Ranch pork, pan fried cornbread, charred onion puree, citrus jerk relish, green chile oil, Two Docks Clams, Castelvetrano olives, thyme, chervil, parmesan, semolina bread, local sustainable fish, white wine, garlic, Everglades butter, tarragon bread crumbs, lemon, Niman Ranch grass fed beef, cheddar, bacon jam, Indigenous sauce, duck fat roasted potatoes, pickled stuff, red bulgur tabbouleh, basil puree, roasted shitakes, lemon jam aioli, parmesan, wild caught Gulf shrimp, cucumbers, carrots, mint, basil, radish, peanuts, fish sauce vinaigrette, vermicelli, sustainable species from reliable sources, vegetables and/or grains, gathered from local sources, Antinori's 2007 Tignanello is wonderfully ripe and seductive in its dark cherries, flowers, spices, tobacco, sage, cedar mint and minerals. Selva Grill is a Peruvian restaurant that specializes in Latin fusion cuisine. They didn't win ,but have lived off that nomination for a long time and the quality has gone down hill since.Pork chop over cooked everything was horribly prepared. . Featuring seasonal American cuisine by award winning Chef/ Owner Stephen Phelps. It appears if you cancel a reservation within 24 hours, theyll charge you a $25 fee. Indigenous. The chef at Indigenous Restaurant cooks good parmesan, mushrooms and cobia. Best restaurant in Sarasota. Needs to become more customer-centered and up its game.More, We went there last night for a Birthday dinner. If youre looking for the best restaurants in downtown Sarasota with outdoor seating, nothing comes close. Clasico also made our list of the best pizza in Sarasota! Absolutely wonderful dinner and the Mushroom Bisque was one of the best soups Ive ever had. Located in a cute neighborhood in a former home, this restaurant was both quaint and elegant. Fortunately, everything we did get was delicious. We tried many things on the menu and everything was to die for. Our favorite. If you love sushi restaurants, youll love this upscale, trendy and super romantic restaurant. The Bodhi Tree Cafe is a super cute restaurant in a quiet neighborhood thats great for dinner. Fortunately, everything we did get was delicious. As of March, Steve Phelps, the co-owner of Indigenous, the award-winning Sarasota restaurant he opened in 2011, has found himself navigating a global pandemic that has ravaged the restaurant industry. Read about this place in a great article in "This week in Sarasota" and I was NOT disappointed. Known for: Ceviche, mirin roasted Chilean sea bass, short rib spring rolls, rack of lamb, lomo saltado, skirt steak and crab cakes. No matter how good the food might have been, the fact that we were treated like dirt spoke volumes. Indigenous Restaurant | 239 S Links Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236, USA Nothing special to start you out that would makeyou remember this place. Enjoy wifi here free of cost. But they are one of the best breakfast spots on Sundays. However you choose to dine, order their fresh catch of the day. Theres also different seating options depending on who youre coming with and how you feel. Restaurant News: Indigenous in Sarasota on responding to pandemic What is pretentious food? The desserts were the best part of the meal. This is definitely another place where locals eat (takeout only). Bricks Smoked Meats is the best barbecue restaurant in downtown Sarasota. Our menu of seasonal American cuisine changes progressively throughout the year based on peak ingredient availability. Indigenous, located in downtown Sarasota's Towles Court neighborhood at 239 S. Links Ave., is known for its focus on sustainable seafood and incorporating ingredients from Florida. If youve ever been to the Sarasota Farmers Market, you simply cant miss it. from the server was that by returning the trout it would be overcooked. Unique dishes with expert-level food presentation. Email restaurant news to ticket@heraldtribune.com. The greeter at the door is a bit rude and the service can sometimes be slow. She said well, we dont like having menus out with appetizers because you may spill on them, and we reuse them. To use our mobile site, please enable JavaScript. Sarasota See all 40 photos Overview Photos Menu Reviews Indigenous 4.7 230 Reviews $31 to $50 American Top Tags: Good for special occasions Neighborhood gem Great for outdoor dining Opened in 2011, Indigenous has earned a reputation for being an inspirational and educational restaurant. Since it opened in 1996, it almost always made the lists of top rated restaurants. Indigenous Chef Steve Phelps Featured on - Sarasota Magazine Any of the fast food joint burgers would have been far superior. The MeLange Restaurant in Sarasota offers the most unique dining experience. Every other fine dining restaurant we went to during our weeks stay had either exceptional bread, dipping oils, spreads, olive plate etc ( you get the picture). Open until 9:00 PM (Show more) Danny and Tricia (owners) are warm, pleasant, polite and their food reflects that. They have a $35 corkage fee just so you know. The homemade pappardelle was so flavorful. It focuses on sustainable seafood & locally sourced ingredients. Save. I have been dining at Indigenous for several years and not once disappointed. Everything was delicious, but we were not able to substitute anything on the menu, ie the dressing couldn't be eliminated on the salad, sauces left over an entree. Maybe a better response would have been that he was sorry it was cold. Waitstaff were all helpful and cheerful. The spectacular service is something these restaurateurs care about. Share. Indigenous Restaurant accepts credit cards. Cuisines American, Bistro, Contemporary American Hours of operation Dinner Tue-Sun 5:30 pm-8:30 pm Phone number (941) 706-4740 Website http://indigenoussarasota.com/ Payment options AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa Dress code Casual Dress Executive chef Chef Steve Phelps Location 239 S Links Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236-2155 Neighborhood Sarasota Informal setting where food is the star of the show. We somehow ended up at the bar at Kojo; if you want to experience genuine hospitality and service, I strongly suggest you go there. My girls shrimp dish was pretty good but nothing special . Americas Best Value Inn Sarasota Downtown. This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Indigenous, 239 S Links Ave, Sarasota, FL, Restaurants Sarasota Restaurants Guide: Top 12 Restaurants in Sarasota, FL more, You seem to have JavaScript disabled. Restaurant News: Sarasota's Indigenous showcased on 'CBS This Morning' Since they are a popular waterfront restaurant, we recommend making a reservation beforehand. The warm atmosphere of this place makes visitors feel relaxed and have a nice time. One of our top five in Sarasota. 95 Points - Wine Enthusiast, The best qualities of both young and aged Cabernet (2005 - 2007). Met my expectations. Chocolate cake was basically a brownie with amateur hour plating. If youre looking for the best restaurants in downtown Sarasota ask the locals. Absolutely fabulous. If youre in the mood for some traditional Italian dishes with a modern twist, give it a try. I dont often feel badly leaving some salad behind - but it was so delicious I ate the entire thing! The second floor dining room is more formal, but doesnt have a dress code. This was our first and last time here. This was the perfect place for a date night/birthday celebration for adults. Thank you for sharing and being our guests. We experienced extremely slow service and pretentious waiters. Indigenous | Restaurants | Sarasota Magazine Yes, Indigenous Restaurant has outdoor seating. They have great music, excellent tacos and amazing margaritas. It screams West coast with its industrial style atmosphere. Drunken Poet Cafe is one of the best Thai restaurants in Sarasota. For years, Indigenous has been known as one of Americas top restaurants, renowned for its passion for food, the community, and the planet. Yes, Indigenous Restaurant has outdoor seating. IndigenousResponded on April 23, 2023Thank you for sharing this. Vegetarian baked falafel was a truly awful idea--without the crunchy shell, falafel is just a lot of paste. The gazpacho was delicious but the pickled shrimp wereovercooked and under seasoned. Thank you. Alternatively, you may use, InterContinental (IHG) Hotels in Sarasota, Hotels near Mote Marine Laboratory & Aquarium, Hotels near Marie Selby Botanical Gardens, Hotels near Big Cat Habitat and Gulf Coast Sanctuary, Hotels near Unconditional Surrender Sculpture, Restaurants near Americas Best Value Inn Sarasota Downtown, Restaurants near Towles Court Artist Colony, Restaurants near McCurdy's Comedy Theatre, Restaurants near Mysterium Escape Rooms & VR, Restaurants near Regal Hollywood - Sarasota, Restaurants near Sarasota Slingshot Rentals, Restaurants near Marie Selby Botanical Gardens, Restaurants near Ringling College of Art and Design, Restaurants near Argosy University Sarasota, Restaurants near East West College of Natural Medicine, Restaurants near Fashion Focus Hair Academy Sarasota, FL, Restaurants near Meridian College Sarasota, FL, Restaurants near Sarasota County Technical Institute, Restaurants near Sarasota School of Massage Therapy, Restaurants near University of South Florida - Sarasota-Manatee Sarasota, FL. Loved the location! Speaking of fees, $35 bottle corkage fee if you bring your own wine.More, Shrimp and scallops horrible! Orders were slow coming out of the tiny kitchen. Its got all the traditional Italian dishes, pizza and award winning pasta. Ama La Vita is a small family owned cozy Italian restaurant. Yes - the wine menu covered all the bases, and we left Indigenous happy and anticipating a return! We told her that we wanted to enjoy our time and didnt want to rush. After dinner, try La Mucca Ballerinas famous tiramisu! I told her not very well. Our server, Kate, was very disappointing. Indigenous Restaurant in Sarasota - Restaurant menu and reviews Indigenous restaurant is Sarasota's newest premier creation. The food is always amazing here. Lastly, our server Kelsey was awesome! Tommy Bahamas Tommy Bahamas has been on of our favorite restaurants since before we moved to Florida. Sandwich Night Is Returning to Indigenous | Sarasota Magazine If youre looking for a vegan restaurant or a vegetarian restaurant, youll love their Vegan & Vegetarian menu. 2022 Sarasota Experts | SEO by R-A-N-K.com, Cotoletta di vitello alla milanese con pomodorini e rucola, Tagliata di Manzo con Salsa al Gorgonzola. Charles de Fere, "Cuvee Jean Louis" Brut, Burgundy FR NV, J" Vineyards Brut, Cuvee 20, Russian River, CA NV, Louis Roederer Brut "Premier", Reims, France NV, Louis Roederer "Cristal" Tete de Cuvee, Reims, France '04, Graff Piesporter Michelsburg Reisling, Mosel, Germany '09, Layer Cake, "Unoaked" Chardonnay, "Hundred Acre", CA '09, Flora Springs "Estate Chardonnay", Napa, CA '09, Pine and Post Merlot, Walla Walla, WA '09, d'Arenberg "The Stump Jump" Shiraz, McLaren Vale, AU '09, Marietta Cellars, Old Vines, Lot 54, Zinfandel Blend, CA, Belle Glos "Meiomi" Pinot Noir, Sonoma, Monterey, Santa Barbara '09, Carpe Diem, Cabernet Savignon, Napa, CA '07, Hook & Ladder, Russian River Valley, Chardonnay, Sonoma, CA '09, Decoy "Duckhorn", Zinfandel, Napa, CA '08, Porter Family Vineyards, Syrah, Napa, CA '06, Porter Family Vineyards, Sandpiper, Cabernet Savignon, Napa, CA '06, Graff Piesporter Michelsburg, Mosel, Germany '09, Pacific Rim, "Organic", Columbia Valley, WA '10, Chateau D' Esclans "Whispering Angel" Rose, Provence, FR '10, Chassagne - Montrachet, Etienne Sauzet, Burgundy, FR '09, Puligny - Montrachet, Olivier Leflaive, Burgundy, FR '08, Layer Cake, "Unoaked", "Hundred Acre", Central Coast, CA '09, Hook & Ladder, Russian River Valley, Sonoma, CA '09, Pahlmeyer Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa, CA '06, Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa, CA '06, Quintessa, Proprietary Red Blend, Rutherford, CA '07. First off its a very nice, quaint , cozy spot. We ordered the fantastic wild mushroom bisque for starters, a regular item on the menu. Apps included Parmesan Beignets and Pork Pupusa. Parmesan apps were ok, curry fish dip was bad.. way too salty and no distinct flavor. Having eaten here before we looked forward to the return visit. Dish needed a vegetable along its potatoes. Yes, you can make a reservation by picking a date, time, and party size. Flavors, original dishes and combinations but lacking a zest of something. One diner thought the shrimp and scallops was bland, the server offered a replacement dish which was the falafel plate - a big improvement. This was my third time dining at Indigenous and the food has always been great! Definitely a miss and overhyped restaurant. 99 Points - Robert Parker, A very fine Cab from the estate. A rather disgusting burger for 24.00. Wegot there at 5:25. Pork chop over cooked everything was horribly prepared. Kelsey our wait person could not have been friendlier or more helpful. Raffurty's Bar and Grill - 1888 Main St, Sarasota. Website. We appreciate the feedback and look forward to seeing you again very soon! Tampa Bay Times food critic Laura Reiley shares her favorite local spots. was good. Indigenous. IndigenousResponded on April 3, 2023Appreciate your feedback. My wife ordered the Burger (waitress said its a great choice). !. A rather disgusting burger for 24.00. Every other fine dining restaurant we went to during our weeks stay had either exceptional bread, dipping oils, spreads, olive plate etc ( you get the picture). Why ask when making a reservation if its for a special occasion and not do anything about it? When it comes to local seafood and outdoor dining, nothing comes close. My fish was cold. Expect gourmet dishes and impeccable presentations. On the palate it is brimming with flavors of wild berries, cassis, and pomegranate, followed by savory notes of mocha, vanilla and round chewy tannins. We then got two orders of shrimp and scallops, redfish and swordfish. Indigenous Restaurant What is it? Overall probably the worst meal for the money during our entire week in Sarasota.More, This was our second visit to Indigenous as we were celebrating a birthday. 6 menu pages, 622 reviews, 1 photo - Indigenous Restaurant menu in Sarasota. The menu changes almost daily depending on what local seafood and vegetables are in season. IndigenousResponded on April 8, 2023Thank you for being our guests! We will never ever set foot in that hostile, arrogant, dismissive place again. The pickled veggies way to vinegary. I highly recommend the char & scallops. 1255 N. Gulfstream Avenue, Suite 101, Sarasota, FL 34236, Five Tasty Takeout Options for When You're Stuck at Home, Vegan, Kale, Paleo, RawHere Are Nourishing Local Meals for Every Kind of Diet, An Out-of-Town Food Critic's Go-To Restaurants in Sarasota and Manatee, This Weekend's Lionfish Derby Combines Hunting and Environmental Conservation. Went here on a date while on vacation. Claim this business. However, many times the kitchen is too busy and they dont take to go orders. (941) 706-4740. Review. We were told in no uncertain terms that we could not enter the building until they got word from inside that it was OK to do so. Known as a trendy eatery with the best happy hour specials and Sunday brunch. Its an upscale restaurant that specializes in French inspired cuisine. . Sarasota Restaurants ; Indigenous; Search "The most overrated restaurant in Sarasota" Review of Indigenous. Caragiulos is an Italian restaurant in downtown Sarasota. We weren't disappointed. Definitely one of the best restaurants for lunch if youre looking for a quick bite to eat. We sat on the patio which was perfect, Without a doubt the best restaurant experience in Sarasota. You are free to download the Indigenous Restaurant menu files. Does Indigenous Restaurant have outdoor seating? Maybe a better response would have been that he was sorry it was cold. Indigenous, Sarasota - Menu, Prices & Restaurant Reviews - Tripadvisor Restaurants are stepping up to offer nourishing meals for every kind of diner and diet. We asked to speak to the GM who are as clearly too busy to take care of his patients to bother finding out what was going on. They flood the mouth with the essence of Cabernet, with ripe blackberries, black currants, raspberries and mocha, and the spicy finish lasts a full minute. Of course I did not want two drinks simultaneously; she did not ask to clarify and when I appeared confused/surprised, she said "I thought that was weird!" Parmesan apps were ok, curry fish dip was bad.. way too salty and no distinct flavor. Youll find many healthy Mediterranean and Italian dishes. First of all, you sit there waiting for your appetizer ( if you ordered one). Indigenous IndigenousResponded on April 15, 2023Thank you. 717 reviews #39 of 605 Restaurants in Sarasota $$$$ American Seafood Vegetarian Friendly. If youre looking for interesting restaurants with great reviews, this is an excellent choice. The waitress came over, and asked how we were doing. Sirved does not guarantee prices or the availability of menu items. Like their menu options, the atmosphere is clean, hip and trendy.